Gluten Free Crunchy Peanut Butter and Chocolate Cookies

Back to all recipes.
Super crunchy gluten free peanut butter cookies with delicious milk chocolate and Reeses peanut butter cup topping. The perfect gluten free cookie for any peanut butter and chocolate lover. These cookies have the best snap to them as well, perfect to have with a good brew. They are easy to make to and fun to decorate, of course you could ditch the Reeses and top with something else instead, how about peanut M&M's or even just some crushed nuts.

This recipe is...

  • Preparation Time: 30 Mins
  • Cooking Time: 30 Mins
  • This recipe makes 14 cookies

This recipe contains:

  • Dairy
  • Peanuts

Last updated 10th October 2024

Added 10th October 2024

Recipe by Alison Peters

Gluten Free Crunchy Peanut Butter and Chocolate Cookies

This recipe was featured in

Ingredients

Cookies
50g unsalted butter
1tbsp golden syrup
65g crunchy peanut butter
100g light brown sugar
180g gluten free self raising flour
Splash of milk

Topping
75g Reeses Mini Peanut Butter Cups or normal Peanut Butter Cups (Approx 4 cups)
200g milk chocolate
Approx 30 Reeses Minis or 3 normal Peanut Butter Cups

Method

NB: Reeses Unwrapped Minis NOT Miniatures are gluten free as are regular peanut butter cups. The miniatures in foil have a may contain warning.

  1. Add the butter and golden syrup to a pan, gently melt over a low heat until just melted and combined.

  2. Pour the butter into a bowl and add the peanut butter and sugar, stir well. For peanut butter I went for a natural 100% peanut butter rather than one with anything added extra - most if not all peanut butters are gluten free.

  3. Sift in the gluten free self raising flour and mix, you want a nice soft handleable dough, it shouldn't crumble apart. If it does crumble add a splash of milk.

  4. Roughly chop the peanut butter cups and add to the dough, gently knead them through the dough so they are fairly evenly spread through.

  5. Roll the dough into a sausage shape you want about a 2inch diameter and around 8 inch in length. Slice it up, I got 14 nice size cookies from it.

  6. Place the rounds on lined baking trays, leave a fair gap between them (I got 7 on a tray) as they do spread a little. Place in an over preheated to gas mark 4/180c and bake for 25-30 mins until a dark golden brown.

  7. Once baked, allow to cool for 10 mins on the tray before lifting off, this gives them time to firm up, then allow them to cool fully for at least half an hour.

  8. Chop or crush more Reeses Peanut Butter Cups and set aside.

  9. Melt the milk chocolate and cover one half of each biscuit, scatter over some of the peanut butter cups so it sticks to the melted chocolate and let set before enjoying with a brew!

Nutritional Information (Per cookie)

Cals
260
Carbs
33g
Fibre
1g
Fat
13g
Sugar
22g
Protein
4g
Alison Peters
Alison Peters has been Coeliac since June 2014 and launched Coeliac Sanctuary in August of that year, and since then has aimed to provide a one stop shop for Coeliacs, from blogs, to recipes, eating out guide and online shop.

Your Comments

There's no comments on this recipe, why not leave one?

Submit Comment

Want to leave a comment on this blog? Feel free to join the discussion!

Note, your email address will never be displayed with your comment, it is only required to alert you when your comment has been approved or if the Coeliac Sanctuary team reply to your comment.

Coeliac Sanctuary

Coeliac Sanctuary, more than a gluten free blog, find gluten free, coeliac safe places to eat, gluten free recipes, blogs, reviews, buy coeliac travel cards and more!

Subscribe to our newsletter

Enter your email address below to get our newsletter sent straight to your inbox!

Copyright © 2014 - 2025 Coeliac Sanctuary.