Gluten Free All Butter Pastry Cherry Pies

Back to all recipes.
I love cherry pies and I have not had one for yours, I always remember having one with my dad when I was young. While I was recovering from surgery I really wanted to make some so with a lot of help I did make some! Ok, it was a team effort, I shouted the orders while hubby did as he was told ha. I made them again since to tweak slightly and they are delicious. Gluten free pastry is not the easiest to master so don't let it put you off it you don't quite get it right first time round.

This recipe is...

  • Preparation Time: 20 Mins
  • Cooking Time: 1 Hour
  • This recipe makes 9 small pies (or alternatively 1 large)

This recipe contains:

  • Dairy
  • Egg

Last updated 8th August 2025

Added 2nd September 2022

Recipe by Alison Peters

Gluten Free All Butter Pastry Cherry Pies

Method

  1. Place the gluten free flour and sugar in a bowl and add the butter in in chunks, rub the butter in using your finger tips until you get a breadcrumb consistency.

  2. Add beaten eggs and a little water (1-2tbsp, try one first and if it is crumbly add a little more) and mix in with a round ended knife until it comes together in clumps, then bring together with your hands, it should all stick together but not crumble apart or be to wet either. Roll up in cling film and chill for 20-30 mins to stiffen.

  3. While chilling add all cherry filling ingredients to a pan and place on a low-medium heat, stir until it starts to combine, but you don't want the cherries to break down too much otherwise you will have cherry jam. Leave to boil until the liquid begins to thicken, about 5 mins. Turn off and leave to cool. It will also thicken more as it cools.

  4. Once you pastry has chilled, roll it out until about 3-4mm thick cut 9 tops and 9 bottoms. I used a 3.5 inch cutter for the bottoms and 2.5inch for the tops.

NB: Alternatively you could make a large pie, just line a pie dish with the pastry, fill and place more pastry on the top, this will need a slightly long baking time (probably 50 mins or so) compared to this recipe.

  1. Grease a muffin tin with vegetable or sunflower oil and line 9 of holes with the bottoms you have cup out. Add a tablespoon or two of the cherries into the centres then place a top on each.

  2. Crimp the edges with a fork to seal, wash with either milk or beaten egg to get a nice golden top then bake on gas mark 4/180c for 30-35 mins until the tops brown.

  3. Remove from the oven and allow to cool before removing from the tin as they are more likely to crumble apart when hot.

Nutritional Information (Per small pie)

Cals
444
Carbs
58g
Fibre
2g
Fat
23g
Sugar
17g
Protein
3g
Alison Peters
Alison Peters has been Coeliac since June 2014 and launched Coeliac Sanctuary in August of that year, and since then has aimed to provide a one stop shop for Coeliacs, from blogs, to recipes, eating out guide and online shop.

Your Comments

There's no comments on this recipe, why not leave one?

Submit Comment

Want to leave a comment on this blog? Feel free to join the discussion!

Note, your email address will never be displayed with your comment, it is only required to alert you when your comment has been approved or if the Coeliac Sanctuary team reply to your comment.

Coeliac Sanctuary

Coeliac Sanctuary, more than a gluten free blog, find gluten free, coeliac safe places to eat, gluten free recipes, blogs, reviews, buy coeliac travel cards and more!

Subscribe to our newsletter

Enter your email address below to get our newsletter sent straight to your inbox!

Copyright © 2014 - 2025 Coeliac Sanctuary.